Tag Archives: Ichiro Suzuki

The Mariners Have An Outfielder Problem. And It’s Not Ichiro.

Leave a reply

The Mariners find themselves with an outfielder problem.

And despite the passionate opinion of a vocal segment of fans, no, it’s not Ichiro.

After being called up from Tacoma at the end of April last year to fill in for the injured Mitch Haniger, Ben Gamel introduced himself to opposing pitchers by blistering the baseball to the tune of .348/.405/.489 in his first 55 games. However, Gamel finished out the remainder of his 2017 season by slashing a sub par .219/.255/.354 over the final 77 contests.

Ostensibly, the Mariners hoped that their projected starting left fielder for 2018 would shake off that 77 game slump in spring training and start the new season closer to how he began it in 2017. However, that did not happen as Gamel missed most all of spring training (and the first two weeks of the regular season) due to a right oblique strain suffered at the beginning of March.

After five weeks on the disabled list, Gamel returned April 18 but the results, so far, have been more of how he ended last year.

In his nine games since returning to the starting lineup, Gamel is slashing a lowly .125/.192/.250 with a .198 wOBA, 22 wRC+, and a -0.2 WAR.

Of course, one must point out the fact this is just a sample size of 24 at-bats in 2018. But when added to that 77 game slash line of .219/.255/.354. (.271 wOBA and a 68 wRC+ during that second half of play) the sample size becomes much more worrisome.

Making matters worse, Gamel’s continuing struggles seem to be affecting how the Mariners are managing their 25-man roster.

With Gamel’s injury, the Mariners brought Ichiro back on a near league-minimum one year deal to temporarily serve as a fill-in. As anyone who has spent any amount of time on social media can tell you, the signing of Ichiro caused much skepticism among certain fans.

That skepticism quickly turned to anger last week when the Mariners decided to demote Gamel’s platoon partner, Guillermo Heredia, along with his .968 OPS, to Tacoma in favor of keeping Ichiro with team.

The Mariners rationalized the move by explaining how the abundance of right-handed starters coming up over the next 10 games would limit Heredia’s playing time.

In baseball reasoning, the move made some sense.

However, while the initial plan was for Ichiro to platoon with Heredia in left field until Gamel returned, at which point the Mariners would then provide Ichiro his walking papers, Gamel’s continuing struggles – at least in part – seem to be causing the Mariners some reluctance to cut ties with the future Hall of Famer.

Ichiro is slashing just a .250/.289/.250 in 38 plate appearances in 2018, but over his last 20 at-bats Ichiro is hitting .300 with a .364 OBP, which is akin to what he produced in the second half of last season when he slashed a .299/.384/.379 with a 108 wRC+.

Although the Mariners surely still see the 25-year-old Gamel as the long-term plan in left field, complicating matters is the fact that at some point Jerry Dipoto is going to have to decide whether continuing to pencil the struggling Gamel into the everyday lineup is not just in Gamel’s best interests, but the Mariners’ best interests as well.

And if Dipoto does choose to, say, send Gamel down to Tacoma to work on his swing much like he did with Mike Zunino last season, the Mariners will need a left-handed hitting outfielder to pair with Heredia.

Hence, Ichiro still being on the roster as insurance.

The wild card factor in all of this comes in the form of the all-star and four-time MVP candidate the Mariners have percolating down in the Rainiers outfield.

Before suffering a series of injuries last season that sidelined him for roughly three months, Jayson Werth was slashing a .262/.367/.446 (.814 OPS) as the everyday left fielder for the Washington Nationals.

Despite being 38 years of age, the Mariners are hoping there is still some of that production left in Werth’s bat shown last season.

With Gamel laboring, Ichiro seemingly on borrowed time, and Heredia not yet showing his is capable of playing every day, it would not be a surprise to see the right-handed hitting Werth eventually up with the Mariners as their everyday starter in left field.

One would surmise that Heredia would then serve as the team’s fourth outfelder, with Ichrio being released and Gamel demoted to Tacoma.

But, then again, if Werth is playing everyday, the Mariners may elect to have both Gamel and Heredia getting everyday at-bats in Tacoma rather than having either one sitting on the bench with the big league club.

And if that ended up being the case, one shouldn’t be surprised to still find Ichiro lingering on the roster serving as Werth’s back-up.

Ichiro: An Ideal Fit for the Mariners

Leave a reply

The Mariners are reportedly bringing Ichiro back. And Mariners fans are throwing a hissy fit over it.

Across the blogosphere, comments such as “the Mariners have given up on the season” and “proof that the Mariners only care about making money” are running rampant.

Even one Mariners blog site equated a possible reunion with Ichiro as the “horrific thought of signing a washed up has been” done so as a mere “money grab.”

Wow.

As the Blacked Eyed Peas would ask, where is the (Ichiro) love?

As we here at Mission Mariner would ask, where is the cognizance?

Or, at least, where is the slight semblance of understanding of the current situation, and the type of players Dipoto and the Mariners look to employ in their outfield?

Instead, news of a possible Ichiro signing has unhooded a large contingency of Mariners fans who seemingly have not been paying attention the past two seasons.

Dipoto has been very vocal in his preference for outfielders that are fast; athletic; provide good defense; can play all three outfield positions; have the ability to make contact; can control the zone and draw a walk; and who can drive the ball from gap to gap.

Ichiro, even at age 44, still checks all the boxes.

Yet, fans have taken to bashing a possible Ichiro signing and, instead, glorifying the remaining free agent barflys such as Jose Bautista, Melky Cabrera, Carlos Gonzalez, and Jon Jay.

All of whom are younger and offer a bit more offensive power than Ichiro, but fall well short of meeting the above-mentioned skill-sets that the Mariners seek.

Of the available free agent outfielders, Jon Jay probably comes the closest, and he is someone we felt could have been an adequate fit for the Mariners to replace Jarrod Dyson.

Jay is still a decent corner outfielder (1.9 UZR in 2017) who produced a .296 average and got on base at a .374 clip while playing 141 games for the Cubs last year.

However, coming off that type of a season, Jay is ostensibly looking for at least semi-regular playing time and a contract to match. As such, the Mariners would have to invest more money (and possibly an additional year) into a player that would be needed as a part-time starter for just the first few months of the year.

That could present a problem for the Mariners when Ben Gamel – seen as the future in left field – returns to the lineup in May.  With the Mariners high on Guillermo Heredia as their fourth outfielder, Jay would suddenly become an expensive fifth outfielder who would most likely take issue with his diminished role on the team.

Ichiro primarily saw time as a pinch hitter in 2017. He started only 22 games, and of his 215 total plate appearances, 109 occurred as a pinch hitter where he produced a .270 average and a .324 on-base percentage.

As any player will tell you, coming of the bench cold to pinch hit is one of the toughest jobs in baseball.  And Ichiro did it quite well last year.

The season before, Ichiro started 62 games and hit .302 with a .358 on-base percentage.

Additionally, Ichiro still possesses above average base running where he has combined for a 1.4 BsR the past two seasons. His contact rate remains solid, averaging an 85% over that same time. Moreover, Ichiro would provide strong defense in left field, as evidenced by his 21.4 UZR/150 and 12.0 UZR/150 in 2016 and 2017.

Clearly, Ichiro is no longer the player he once was when he first came to the Mariners. But his production the past two seasons indicates that he is still someone who can provide the type of production the Mariners value as a semi-regular starter as well as a pinch hitter, the latter of which would become his role once Gamel returns from the disabled list.

More importantly, Ichiro understands who he currently is as a player at this stage of his career, and what is expected from him.

With the Mariners looking for a temporary starter in left field who would then become a pinch hitter, pinch runner, and late game defensive replacement when Gamel returns, Ichiro is the ideal fit.

And once Mariners fans stop judging Ichiro against the player he used to be, and start understanding the areas of value he can still provide, the love will return.